I know a lot of people who use Netflix, myself being one of them. I don't, however, know of anyone who uses Gamefly. Correction: I may know one person, but I don't recall ever really hearing them talk about it.
On the surface, Gamefly seems like a really good idea. It's the same principle as Netflix, but with videogames. Using the service lets you try before you buy. Most video stores have a game section, as well, and I don't really utilize that either. And I have a pretty valid reason why.
I don't like renting games.
It's a little more complicated than that really. Renting a game already puts pressure on the idea of getting it back to the rental agency in a timely manner. Gamefly doesn't have late fees (that I know of), but there is still that pressure that you want to get your money's worth. To do that, you have to rent a set number of games. I don't want to be pressured to get a game back at a certain time. I want to take my time with it, enjoy it at a leisurely pace. Renting doesn't let me do that, and that's why I shy away from it. Of course, that means I have to buy them, and that leaves me vulnerable to spending hard-earned money on a subpar game.
That has happened from time to time, though I know my tastes well enough to know whether or not I will enjoy a game, and reviews help work out issues that have nothing to do with tastes like bugs or poor controls and camera. Because of this, I end up with games I enjoy more often than not, and if I don't or if I tire of them, I can sell them on eBay or some place like that dungeon Gamestop.
I think Gamefly works fine for plenty of people, but it isn't for me or anyone else who wants to take their time with a game. For those who don't have the time to dig into every games reviews or the money to take a chance on a game they may not enjoy, it is actually fairly idea. It shouldn't take too long to realize whether or not you like a game enough to want to buy it, and in that sense the company is a godsend.
If anyone has any thoughts on the company, I'd love to hear them because my daughter has asked me about it, and I think it may be worth getting for her if only because her desire to play games is less so than mine, and she is far more fickle. Let me know if you think it is worth it, what you pay, what problems you've had and so on.